Showing posts with label Jared Diamond. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jared Diamond. Show all posts

Friday, 21 June 2013

Birds of a feather continued ...

                                                        NASTY monkey!                                                               Up, Down.                 Longest Day 

Canterbury Tales mural by Ezra Winter, 1939.English Grade 12 in Quebec in the early 6o's is some kind of middle ground (in many dimensions - it's Montréal's West Island). University-style lectures for English Literature in a large steeply-sloped room and the Norton Anthology, a huge book to carry around. Our teacher is a white-haired lady who knows how to speak Middle English - one of the first actually 'educated' people I (ever) meet. She reads aloud to us some of the prologue to The Canterbury Tales and I will never forget the sound of her voice. She also knows how to properly perform public speaking with no microphone required. Another one I remember is:
        Roll on, thou deep and dark blue Ocean — roll!
        Ten thousand fleets sweep over thee in vain.

                   
(From Childe Harold's Pilgrimage fourth canto verse CLXXIX (179) 1812-1818, Lord Byron.)

She rocks the place ... but that's another story ... 
Chaucer doesn't write about the Great Rising which must be going on at about the time The Canterbury Tales are being written & performed in whatever way they're disseminated. He is the king's bureaucrat and a 'moneyer', and it just wouldn't do. And the likes of Wat Tyler & John Ball don't ride to Canterbury with good pilgrim burghers either I guess.

Readers of this blog will know that I have been looking at the holocaust a bit over the last few years - there are tags: Holocaust, Rwanda ... There is a section on my bookshelf with Primo Levi, Henry Kreisel, Hannah Arendt, Georgio Agamben, Zygmunt Bauman ...

Jared Diamond, 2013.Jared Diamond, sometime in the 80s or 90s.But by a coincidence I don't read Jared Diamond's take on it. Last week, after his notions on agriculture shake me violently up and down, the very next (or so) chapter in The Third Chimpanzee is 16: In Black and White ... on genocide. 
I plod along, slowly coming to realize that genocide perpetrators are ordinary folks; wondering how that could be? And then BOOM!   It is frequent if not continuous if not structurally necessary to human development and history; the 1994 Rwanda genocide has antecedents, an extended context, background; species kill their own kind as their capabilities permit.

The Third Chimpanzee is published in 1992 and mentions Hutus & Tutsis but not the 1994 case. Diamond subsequently brings his thinking up-to-date in Chapter 10 of Collapse - Malthus in Africa: Rwanda's Genocide.

I won't belabour it - like I said before he is not trustworthy. Read these things and digest and absorb them if and as you will.

... consider that torture is a high art, refined, subtle, technologically advanced - and has been ... forever; or Chinese lotus feet and infibulation (both male and female); or that 90% of Nazi death camp commandants were nominally Catholics. 
The idea that human nature has fundamentally (as it were) changed very much since Chaucer's time is simple nonsense. The bourgeois bromide 'Life is Sacred'   ditto. How did I get this old and have no clue?

My son asks several times in the last few years why I bother trying to raise consciousness of the environmental debacle which is coming down - and my reasons really come (again beginning in that Øth chakra, the kundalini fundament) through some women I meet in Brazil, and Oxum and Iansã and Iemanjá, and a reaction I have to knowing that the first hard rain will fall upon them and people much like them and their kids.

(Anyone who don't know that men relate to the world through their pricks don't know much. Not the one-and-only, neither the be-all nor the end-all; but certainly right up there among the very first of objective correlatives. With respect to my mother for her part in teaching me this.)

I am surprised at the quickness of these jagged pieces falling so certainly into place in the jigsaw ... click.

Bottom line gentle reader is that looking at the humanity I see these days doesn't show much reason to be striving for climate- or eco- or any other kind of justice. Is this the cockeroach in the ointment? Is this why the 'movement' is not... moving?
( Just askin' y'unnerstan' ... )                     Be well.
Later on sometime:    ... Sure it's personal.

How not to wonder and ask the obvious questions: What is my share in deserving oblivion? How much of this is mine? Who needs this species and what is it good for beyond some sentimental attachments to the music of Bach & Handel?

Homo erectus, Homo sapiens ... Homo grǽdum? Homo agapiens? Which will it be and, who can say?Walt Kelly: Pogo, Earth Day 1971.

It becomes less difficult to understand transcendental end-runs: inventing gods and devils; putting it all more-or-less comfortably 'out there' to be dealt with 'objectively' (or trying to). And too, understanding that (vain? futile?) temptation compassionately (or trying to).

It is never pleasant to be faced with another's pain & suffering; less to have to cut into your own existence for any reason.

Anyway, it's not 2015 yet. There's still time to turn it around. And we're not quitters are we? That's what I say to my son as we sit looking out into an urban land- socio- spirit-scape which we agree there is no good reason to preserve.

[Lamer than usual gentle reader; oh well ... "How're ya gonna keep 'em down on the farm after they've seen Paree?"] 

Down.

Friday, 14 June 2013

Birds of a feather flock together.

                                                                                                                                                                   Up, Down.        Great Rising 1381 

[Unrelated, but I strongly recommend a close look at the latest issue of 'Policy' (freely-downloadable pdf here) 'The Great Canadian Energy Puzzle' including articles by Elizabeth May, Jim Prentice, and Joe Oliver (our very own Alfred E. Newman, direct from Mad) among others.]

In 2011, somewhere in the vicinity of Rancho Mirage ... the Koch brothers hold a summit:
Greenpeace blimp in the vicinity of Rancho Mirage.Greenpeace blimp in the vicinity of Rancho Mirage.Greenpeace blimp in the vicinity of Rancho Mirage.
Coke, Koch, Koch, Koch, Pet, Petcoke, Koch:
Coke.Bill Koch.Charles Koch.David Koch.Julia Koch.Petcoke, Detroit.Koch Industries.
Bankety bankety bank ... with help from Ogden Nash (1902–1971):
Jamie Dimon & Lloyd Blankfein.Jamie Dimon & Lloyd Blankfein.Jamie Dimon & Lloyd Blankfein.Jamie Dimon & Lloyd Blankfein.Goldman Sachs/JP Morgan Chase & Co.
Goldman Sachs/JP Morgan Chase & Co.Judith & Jamie Dimon.Judith & Jamie Dimon.Laura & Lloyd Blankfein.
... they deserve our appreciation and thanks, the jackasses who go around saying that health and happiness are everything and money isn't essential, because as soon as they have to borrow some unimportant money to maintain their health and happiness they starve to death so they can't go around any more sneering at good old money, which is nothing short of providential.
 
With silver bells and cockle shells and pretty maids all in a row:
Mark Carney, Christian Noyer, Alex Weber, Ben Bernanke, Mario Draghi, Masaaki Shirakawa.Mark Carney, Christian Noyer, Alex Weber, Ben Bernanke, Mario Draghi, Masaaki Shirakawa.Mark Carney, Christian Noyer, Alex Weber, Ben Bernanke, Mario Draghi, Masaaki Shirakawa.
In 2013 at the Annenberg Retreat, Sunnylands (also somewhere in the vicinity of Rancho Mirage):中国梦   'Chinese Dream'. The translation coming via Google Translate (and keep in mind that someone like me who does not even know if Chinese is read right to left or up and down is not to be trusted).

Jared Diamond in 2010.Jared Diamond is not to be trusted either. A strange looking fellow - no harm in that. I was with him until Chapter 15 of his book 'Collapse' - Big Businesses and the Environment: Different Conditions, Different Outcomes - at which point the whitewash/greenwash of Chevron in Papua New Guinea left me ... gobsmacked!

But times are tough - I am running out of books to read and can't afford to buy more - so 'The Third Chimpanzee' finds its way to my bedside table and in a few days I get to Chapter 10 - Agriculture's Mixed Blessings. IT SHAKES MY CONSTELLATION! I sleep and have nightmares. 
Paleolithic Female Triangle, Ölknitz.Next morning I am still breathless. Not because of the scholarship - which I am unsure of (anyway, how would I know?); and not the cogency of the arguments which are not particularly ... more like the day when some little girl finally lifts her dress and you catch your first glimpse of coochie.

Ah, a bona fide translation: 和悦梦想   'Harmonious Happy Dream' (with at least one ideogram in common) at Peggy Liu's JUCCCE (Joint US-China Collaboration on Clean Energy).

Candide's Garden.My own (simpleminded and sentimental) harmonious dream runs to a meadow, a cabin, a brook, a garden in which to dig & delve, very Thoreau, and as anima an Abishag who at least occasionally smiles. Never to be gentle reader ... once upon a time I offer an onion farm in São José do Norte to a beloved friend and she says "Sou preta mas não escrava / I am black but not a slave." Oh well ...

This notion of Diamond's strikes directly at that garden eh?

There is a copy posted on-line to read and think about maybe. That's it.
Be well. 

Even Paul Krugman almost gets it - but not quite. A 'strong social safety net' he says. Yes, he's got that right; but he is addicted to corporate ideology (has to be because for him it is an existential condition); and he still thinks some policy committee or other armed with tax money can accomplish good - which is nonsense.

Valdenir Munduruku & friend leaving Brasília.There are important clues (as to what a real safety net might look like) in the behaviour of Valdenir Munduruku and his friends and colleagues over the past several months as they confront the infernal machine that builds the likes of Belo Monte.

They are getting safely home again after a struggle in which they risked all - in this I heartily rejoice. Sadder but wiser - and it isn't over yet.
 

Sunday, 18 September 2011

Cada pessoa é um mundo ...

Each person is a world ...
Up, Down, Postscript.

Lois Frank & Máijá Tailfeathers facing the trucks.¡Ya basta!Three women of the Kainai Nation; Lois Frank, Jill Crop Eared Wolf, and Elle-Máijá Tailfeathers; were arrested for blocking three Murphy Oil trucks carrying fracking fluid onto the reserve near Standoff, Alberta (map) on September 10.

For some reason Google Maps shows the rivers but not their names: Oldman River, St. Mary River, and Belly River.

Máijá Tailfeathers arrested.Jill Crop Earred Wolf arrested.Jill Crop Earred Wolf & Lois Frank arrested.Lois Frank arrested.Facing the Reserve Police.It looks to me like Murphy Oil Corporation with the connivance of the various levels of so-called 'government' bought all of those nice diesel pickup trucks you can see (and hear) there in the videos, and along with them the Kainai Band Council, but it wasn't enough to shut up these women and their colleagues. There is at least one man involved - Arnell Tailfeathers, a brother (I think) to Máijá, and who (I think) took the videos.

Here are the videos:
       1) Introduction: Máijá Tailfeathers & Cathy Brewer,
       2) The site: Máijá Tailfeathers,
       3) The arrests, and,
       4) The trucks go rolling on through.

There is a report at CBC, but better is at CENSORED NEWS by Brenda Norrel:
       Sunday, September 11, 2011: Elle-Máijá Tailfeathers Statement, and,
       Tuesday, September 13, 2011: Fracking Mother Earth for Dollars.

The network is paying off - I got this news on the very day from Tar Sands Action, the organizers of the Washington protest: 3 Blood Tribe Women Arrested in Fracking Blockade.

There was some applause from supporters as they were arrested - and there has been some applause in this little apartment too as I have been putting this together.

Good on you!

Toxic k-k-Canada.I spent some time in that foothills country - in the 80's putting up windmills (and taking them down again in the 90's) at the now defunct Alberta Renewable Energy Test Site near Pincher Creek (also on that map).

If you are unclear on just what 'fracking' is, you can start here.

The latest report I can find (as I am about to post this) is from Wednesday the 14th in the Calgary Herald.

Here's something else: UBC graduate Elle-Máijá Tailfeathers stands up for the Bloodlands by Shannon O'Rourke in The Ubyssey, September 20, and, her film Bloodlands plays at Empire Granville 7 Theatre on October 6 and 11: VIFF Listing.

A-and a bit more: (October 4 update) A short piece on CBC Radio from September 22, and a link I meant to include before: Protect Blood Land, now with the news that court proceedings have been delayed until October 17 for the three women arrested on September 10th.

by Rodrigo Chaves.
From Rodrigo Chaves' blog Contratempos Modernos.



Each person is a world, with a history, a geography, biodiversity ...


To know a person is to explore this world. Some are immediately interesting.


On others it is necessary to explore more thoroughly.


And obviously there are some who do not permit visits.


Thanks to Miss Numa.Thanks to Miss Numa.
I saw this on Miss Numa's blog Miss Numa Gloves You back in August when she posted it, and it stuck but I didn't know why - that the veils are reminiscent of the Orixás perhaps.

Then, turning over the old compost heap yesterday, it came to me - The Three Graces: Aglaea (Splendor), Euphrosyne (Mirth), and Thalia (Good Cheer). A-and Wikipedia calls them 'The Charites' - which set off another one of those damned tectonic shiftings I have been experiencing lately - mini-strokes maybe (hopefully).

(I have been stumbling around in this territory before, looking for my lost & distant girls Oxum & Iansã and their source Iemanjá ... and Anima and Abishag of course.)

There is a nexus here so deep and wide ... but it was not until today that I followed the trail from the graceful charites through caritas to agapé.

So ... thanks to Miss Numa, who simply called them 'rather delish'.

Another one so soon?! Yup. Here's Alzheimer's
'Vantage #8: Out with a friend to a restauraunt where we shared a delicious Italian dessert. But I cannot remember the name of it - could not indeed remember it at the time for more than 20 seconds (for some reason). So, as long as I remember that there was a dessert at all I will be calling to have the name given to me again. It promotes social interaction do you see? Solidarity.Let's hear it for Lizard Brain! :-)
I am betting that the olfactory & gustatory will outlast language. (I have the telephone number written down.) And not a bad bet either - since I believe these senses reside in that old fave-o-rite: the hypothalamus (or substantia nigra is it? amygdala? hippocampus?) ... anyway, the Lizard Brain - you know what I mean.

When mom was going down with it and took a mouthful of sweet custard you could see a change, a kind of a ghost of a smile, just a hint of some vague residual recognition of pleasure.

I am longing to exercise that closing cadence 'My tale is done, a mouse has run' upon this blog. In fact, I did use it here ... more than a year ago, but it didn't stick. Oh well.

I am such a pushover. I can clutch longer at slimmer (even invisible) straws than ... (It's not over yet, so ... Who Knows?) One of my ex's expressed mild & indirect approbation when I participated in Washington and in a flash I was back in love all over again.Easy AND cheap. :-)

It don't take much.  
(As I hum a few bars of Guess Who's American Woman ... and then ... Undun.)

¡Ya basta!I went looking for some of the other Canadians from Toronto who were in Washington. I thought maybe we could get together and do something to promote the planned demonstration in Ottawa on the 26th - but it looks like none of them want any, and the organizers have now ignored three offers of support (beyond mere attendance). So ...

Here are some possibly useful links:
       VIA Rail - $155.94 Toronto return,
       Greyhound Canada - $125.00 Toronto return,
       Ottawa Backpacker's Inn - $25 per night, and,
       Hostelling International Ottawa (in the old jail) - from $28.
Be aware that there are various discounts for early booking, age, and so on, so these numbers are just indicators.

Estimates are for 400-500 demonstrators in Ottawa on the 26th. I thought this was not enough. But - it would be about twice any given day of the Washington action. So ... close enough to significant & substantial for the girls I go with!

David is relieved to find his depression isn't about him, but rather a massive disappointment in the human race.But ... What am I doing wrong then? That so many of my overtures are rejected? What can it be? I don't get it. Either I really am (unbeknownst to myself - is that even possible with the written word?) entirely incoherent. Or am I working secretly and undercover (and schizophrenically I guess, psychotically) for CSIS & the RCMP? Is that it?

Or, as I often fear these days, am I - completely and on every conceivable axis and in every conceivable dimension - simply ... wrong?

Or ... or ... it's a remnant ... an aberration generated in some vestigial circuit of hope à la Allen Ginsberg & his Howl: "waiting for a door in the East River to open full of steamheat ..." Maybe it is not Alzheimer's at all, nor even age. Maybe it is a mind-virus disrupting, expanding, transferring, propagating by some corrupt but invisible intellectual process ... (Ggah!)

Surely my kids would see such a thing and tell me. Wouldn't they? I talk to them all the time.

Aha! A Clue! One of the companheiras from Washington has sent me a blast, trying to whack my pee-pee for being politically incorrect in my language. She missed ... but sure ... She's right! I am so not a devotee of correctitude. Could it be as simple as that? Ai ai ai!

I will try to fathom just how correctitude fits (or doesn't fit more likely) into this nexus and let you know.

Thank you Madam for this honesty, howevermuch unintentional & inverted. It is already useful to me.

I have been wondering about Jared Diamond: How could such a smart guy, so articulate and competent and so obviously full of life, sell out to Chevron? (See Chapter 15 of Collapse.)

So I have set about reading some of his books, as carefully as I can, thinking about him, wondering ... maybe I will have something to say about it all later on sometime ... one of these days:

1991: The Third Chimpanzee: The Evolution and Future of the Human Animal at Wikipedia & the Toronto Public Library (TPL),

 

1997: Why Is Sex Fun? The Evolution of Human Sexuality at Wikipedia & TPL,

 

1997: Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies at Wikipedia & TPL,

 

2005: Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed at Wikipedia & TPL, and,

 

2010: Natural Experiments of History not included in Wikipedia but yes, at TPL.

 
In The Third Chimpanzee: the evolution and future of the human animal, at the end of Chapter 17 - The Golden Age That Never Was, I found this poem:

My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings.I met a traveller from an antique land
Who said: "Two vast and trunkless legs of stone
Stand in the desert. Near them on the sand,
Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown
And wrinkled lip and sneer of cold command
Tell that its sculptor well those passions read
Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,
The hand that mocked them and the heart that fed.
And on the pedestal these words appear:
'My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!'
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away".


       (Ozymandias by Percy Bysshe Shelley)

Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!Of course I already knew it - I think we had to memorize it back in the day, Grade 8 or maybe Grade 9. And there is a mystery in this poem as well: What does, "the hand that mocked them and the heart that fed," refer to exactly I wonder? Another question for another day.

I will carry this poem to Ottawa on the 26th - in the event that someone asks me what I am doing there I will have an answer at hand.

Chapter 18 of The Third Chimpanzee, Blitzkrieg and Thanksgiving in the New World, is quite short, quick to read, and challenges some politically correct notions around the privileged aboriginal relatonship with nature and the environment - and challenges them successfully to my mind. I have been in the bush with First Nations' people who were no more in tune with it than I was (I mean to say: I was, and they were, but no more d'y'unnerstan'?).

Meditations around despair inevitably touch upon suicide. Those I feel closest to these days in considering environmental issues have despaired and, like myself, keep on keepin' on for ever more subtle and difficult-to-describe-in-smalltalk reasons. I met several people in Washington who were there and who share (approximately) my despair (or something like it).

One of them pointed me at this audio webcast of David Webb, and links to his book Thinking of Suicide (unhappily not available at the Toronto Public Library), and to an earlier report of his, The Many Languages of Suicide.

One evening in Rio - this happened right across the street from the famous Garota da Ipanema, where they say The Girl from Ipanema was composed - I had been working too hard and not eating and I collapsed over two choppes and a grilled-cheese sandwich. Luckily, waiters in Rio are not afraid to touch you so they soon had me picked up and into a chair and I came to. I didn't even remember falling. One of my mates saw me to my door later on, just in case. But, as we were walking slowly up the street, I was thinking to myself, "So, that's it then? If I had died I would never have known. When the time comes I can do that - easy."

One of those rare moments of freedom.

David Webb several times asks the question, "What would a compassionate society look like?" Good question!

It would certainly not look much like the urban and sub-urban societies of the early 21st century, for starters. (I said that.)

The United Church of Canada Crest.I hope this is not too long a jump, but: Compassion does not fit into institutions and cannot be made to fit there. A bureaucracy cannot dispense compassion. Compassion can neither be legislated nor enforced. As soon as your church makes it into doctrine it flies away from your church. As soon as you have applied a bumper-sticker to your car saying 'Be Compassionate!" it has flown right away from you.

About the same goes for compassion's first-cousin, 'empathy'. I say 'about' because marketing researchers and such like sleveens do try to use it - sometimes with effect, albeit negative; and because weeping sometimes, over Internet videos of courageous actions and eloquent speeches may (does sometimes) evoke a sort of verisimilitude.

I would go farther and say that compassion only raises its eyes & reveals its visage when you are close enough to someone to reach out and physically touch them. But that might be a step too far, and anyways I am still learning.

One thing David Webb says, which bears very directly, is this: "Speaking openly about suicidal feelings, rather than reacting with panic and fear, is the best ..."

And not true just for suicide either I'll warrant.

No doubt it is nothing but a coincidence that some Americans are simultaneously ruminating (in their way) over related issues:
       Paul Krugman: Free to Die, September 15 2011, and,
       Peter Catapano: Let’s Talk About Death, September 16 2011.

Be well gentle reader.

Kumi Naidoo.Kumi Naidoo - after 2009 hunger-strike.Postscript:

(The Wikipedia bio seemed incomplete, so I cobbled this together.)

Kumi Naidoo Bio:
Born in South Africa in 1965, Kumi Naidoo became involved in the South African liberation struggle at the age of 15. As a result of his anti-apartheid activities, he was expelled from high school. He was deeply involved in neighbourhood organisation, youth work in his community, the underground movement, and mass mobilisations against the apartheid regime.

In 1986, he was arrested and charged for violating the state of emergency regulations. He went underground for one year before finally fleeing into exile in the UK until 1989. During this time, he was a Rhodes Scholar at Oxford and earned a doctorate in political sociology. After Nelson Mandela's release in 1990, Kumi returned to South Africa to work on the legalisation of the African National Congress. During the democratic elections in 1994, he was the official spokesperson of the Independent Electoral Commission and directed the training of all electoral staff in the country.

Kumi became the founding Executive Director of the South African National NGO Coalition (SANGOCO), an umbrella agency for the South African NGO community. Provoked by the fact that South Africa has one of the highest rates of violence against women, Kumi was lead organiser of the National Men's March Against Violence on Women and Children in 1997.

From 1998 until 2008, Kumi Naidoo was the Secretary General and Chief Executive Officer of CIVICUS: World Alliance for Citizen Participation. With a small staff of 40, but a membership of more than 1000 organisations and individuals from more than 100 countries, CIVICUS is dedicated to strengthening citizen action and civil society throughout the world. He is currently the honorary president of CIVICUS.

Kumi is a Rhodes Scholar with a D.Phil. in Politics from Magdalen College, Oxford. He also holds a BA in Politics and Law from the University of Durban-Westville, South Africa. He has published and spoken widely on issues relating to civil society, education, and resistance to apartheid.

Kumi Naidoo took up the role of Executive Director of Greenpeace International in November 2009.


Kumi Naidoo.Some videos of Kumi Naidoo:

Conversation with Thom Hartmann, and part 2 (about 15 minutes each).

 

Speech at CCLA March 2011, part 2, part 3 (about 15 minutes each).

 

Speech at the Copenhagen Global Day of Action, December 2009 (10 minutes).

 

Greenpeace at 40 Years, a conversation between Rex Weyler & Kumi Naidoo.

 
Some (possibly related) miscellaneous links:

Desmond Tutu at Copenhagen Rally in 2009 (a version from the United Church of k-k-Canada), and another video, less complete but with more closeups.

 

Food & Trees for Africa

 

The Climate Reality Project (Why is there nothing of this in Toronto?)

 
Finally, a report of Kumi Naidoo's 2009 hunger strike (written by himself) and a Guardian Interview from July 2009.

I just thought it was time to get to know this man a little better. The speeches are competent but not all flattering to him. Nonetheless he is indeed a fit champion. Actions speak louder than words.

Toxic k-k-Canada.The headline in my Canadian Climate Action Network weekly newsletter trumpets, "Victory! Kent says Maxim coal won't be allowed to skirt the rules."
Weasel
'Damned Pollyanna optimists!' I think. Everyone knows that Peter Kent is a spineless weasel, and I doubt there has been any real victory over him (yet).

Sure enough, the CTV article they reference has it as, "Ottawa warns pending emissions rules will be enforced," but working your way west, to Winnipeg , where it is still "Kent threatens to tighten coal plant emissions rules," you fetch up with a thump in Calgary & Edmonton where it is "No surprises likely in new coal rules, Kent says."

QED.


In an effort to cut down on copy&paste I am keeping text copies of some of the articles I reference here so that if-and-when the link dies and if-and-when I notice it (or someone tells me) I can post them then. This makes it a bit slower to get at them - apologies.

Down.