Thursday, 25 June 2009

Garbage, Yee Haa!

Up, Down.

Bill & Bobby Hennessey www.strikegarbage.comSpiralsqueeze 'em till they shriek!

if you can bear the ridiculous ad prefix you can watch the Toronto Thought Police catch some wobegone old fart ditching a bag of garbage in a park, there you go, the guy looks like he can hardly walk, if that is a function of his owning a car or not I can't say ...

but it is a problem that must be dealt with, the Mayor and the Premier call it an "inconvenience" but speaking as an old fart, who does not have a car, living in a small apartment, sometime later next week I will have to do something about the garbage piling up in my tiny freezer, either sneak out late at night to the park next door, or call these guys: www.strikegarbage.com, couple'a maritimers, Bill & Bobby Hennessey, probably have to pay 'em 50$, for one bag, oh well

the reason I am posting this is to put a bit of energy behind the Hennessey brothers (1), and vent some spleen of course, some kind of balance has to be maintained ... Rick Salutin has another take on it

meanwhile, these 'entitled' union workers, and others for that matter, might want to consider that 800 British Airways workers set to work unpaid, and something I don't want to forget ... but which I probably should - Somali Sharia amputations.

Backbench, John Baird Federal Transport Ministerthis is our "government": we have the braggart & bully ex-Environment Minister, John Baird, trashing (2) public transport in the name of consistent bureaucracy

AND we have the good-old-oil-bum-boy & weasel current Environment Minster, Jim Prentice, diverting funds from renewables to the Tar Sands of Fort McMurray (3), and Little Bo Peep Lisa Raitt worries about being blamed for the leak, she should be PROUD OF BEING THE LEAK GODDAMMIT!!!

AND we have Health Canada running John O'Connor out of Fort Chipewyan (4), these maggots have the eternal gall to claim he was incompetent? question his credentials at the CMA?

Dr. John O'Connor Fort ChipewyanDr. John O'Connor Fort ChipewyanDr. John O'Connor Fort ChipewyanDr. John O'Connor Fort Chipewyan

it beggars the imagination ...


IT BEGGARS
THE FUCKING
IMAGINATION
!
a big ol' thunder storm just came along to give Toronto a bit of a wash, I love thunderstorms, always have ... my father used to wake us up in the middle of the night and carry us to the front porch to sit and watch them from under the safety of a huge army-surplus rain poncho he had, and then he would carry us back up and tuck us in, ai ai ai

my good friend comes for a visit now and then, he was over the other night and tells me I have to cool it or the anger is going to undo me, and of course he is right ... times like these my mind turns to beautiful brown skinned beauties with their tits out ('peitos de fora'), if anyone reads this nonsense regularly they may very well think that I am a 'viejo verde' a 'green old man' in Spanish (which is all the Spanish I ever learned), it is not the same idiom in Portuguese, 'safado' is about the equivalent, and, fair enough, maybe I am a dirty old man, in that case I guess you could do worse

SpiralI wonder if 'nubile' comes from Leni Riefenstahl's pictures of naked Nuba girls in Sudan? ... nope, OED tells me latin nubilis ready to marry, and nubere to marry

but, believe it or not, it is evidence of character that catches my attention, or what little evidence could be said to be found in a photograph of a person you do not know ... whatever ... here are some portraits of women from Rita Willaert at Flickr, the Nuba people of Sudan:


Nuba Woman Nyaro SudanNuba Woman Nyaro SudanNuba Woman Nyaro SudanNuba Woman Kau SudanNuba Woman Kau SudanNuba Woman Kau SudanNuba Woman Kau SudanNuba Woman Kau Sudan

***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
Appendices:
1. 'Garbaneurs' Garbage strike doesn't stink for everyone, Brodie Fenlon, Wednesday June 24 2009.
2. City scrambles to save $1.2-billion streetcar project, Jennifer Lewington, Thursday June 25 2009.
3. Prentice moved wind power funds to oil sands projects: Raitt tape, CBC, Thursday June 11 2009.
4. In Depth: Fort Chipewyan, CBC, November (?) 2008.
5. 800 BA workers set to work unpaid, BBC, Thursday 25 June 2009.
6. Somalis watch double amputations, BBC, Thursday June 25 2009.
7. Swallow self-respect? Er, no thanks, Rick Salutin, Friday June 26 2009.
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
'Garbaneurs' Garbage strike doesn't stink for everyone, Brodie Fenlon, Wednesday June 24 2009.

For enterprising Torontonians, one man's trash is another man's profit

Bill Hennessey sees gold in them hills of trash.

The 25-year-old live lobster salesman-turned-event promoter has whipped up a website and organized disposal trucks in a mad dash to capitalize on Toronto's garbage strike.

His instant business, Toronto Sameday Garbage Removal, launched Tuesday with Mr. Hennessey, his brother and a cube van going door-to-door in North Toronto, offering to pick up bags of trash.

The self-described “garbaneurs” see no limit to the gains they can make off Toronto's pain. Mr. Hennessey said he has proper disposal trucks lined up for the weekend, and a deal to dump the waste at a landfill outside the city (he wouldn't say where).

As for what he'll charge, he's coy. Mr. Hennessey said he'll “figure it out as we go based on market demand,” though he is aiming for about $50 per home in the beginning.

“We'll come to your door. We'll take everything the City of Toronto would typically take,” he said. “Who wants a stinky garage? As you know if you've been to a transfer station, it's a hassle.”

Indeed, Mr. Hennessey stands to make a small fortune if yesterday's experience at some transfer stations continues. In Scarborough, residents waited several hours under the blazing sun to cross the picket line. A manager working as a bylaw officer shooed away cars that parked too close to the gates, and threatened other residents with fines for illegal dumping.

“If this persists for three or four more weeks, it's going to be a nightmare. People are going to be dumping,” said a woman in line with two bags. She declined to give her name. “Who can afford to stand here and wait three hours?”

Toronto's last garbage strike in 2002 was a boon to private trash haulers. Many charged premium prices, although some, like 1-800-GOT-JUNK, turned down work out of respect for striking workers.

For someone new to the rubbish business, Mr. Hennessey cuts a polished figure: His hair is coiffed, his sunglasses mirrored, and the sales patter spills easily off his tongue.

The Charlottetown native and business graduate from the University of Western Ontario runs a live lobster delivery service that ships crustaceans summer-long to Muskoka.But he saw a new opportunity while sifting through Monday's newspaper headlines after Toronto's 24,000 indoor and outdoor workers walked off the job, shutting down daycares, recreation centres and garbage collection.

“I saw the garbage strike and said that's going to be an issue for all families ... I'm sure there's demand for this service.”

For more on Mr. Hennessey's business, visit www.strikegarbage.com.


***************************************************************************
City scrambles to save $1.2-billion streetcar project, Jennifer Lewington, Thursday June 25 2009.

With June 27 deadline looming, city officials plan special meeting to approve funding

A special Toronto city council meeting - with the mayor and councillors having to cross picket lines in the middle of the current civic workers' strike - may be called as early as today to save a $1.2-billion streetcar project.

The possibility of such a dramatic move comes as city officials scramble to meet a June 27 deadline for the Toronto Transit Commission to sign a contract with Bombardier Inc., of Montreal, to replace 204 streetcars starting in 2012.

Adding to the intrigue was an offer in the works from Mayor David Miller's council critics, who say they would agree to the special meeting tomorrow or Saturday to approve streetcar funding, if they could also re-open debate on a freeze on councillor salaries.

"If we are going to cross the picket line, we also should have a discussion about councillor salaries," said councillor Karen Stintz (Ward 16 Eglinton-Lawrence), a possible mayoral challenger.

While the mayor and at least 18 councillors have voluntarily given up a 2.4-per-cent cost of living increase in their salaries this year, council's right-wing minority has tried unsuccessfully to impose a freeze on all 44 councillors. The down-to-the wire scramble on streetcars is the latest twist in a high-stakes political drama heightened when the federal government confirmed last week that the project - with a key option for up to 400 light-rail vehicles for Toronto's "Transit City" project - would not qualify for Ottawa's short-term stimulus funds.

Last December, the city pledged one-third of the cost for the replacement streetcars, with matching funds pledged last week by Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty. The two governments hoped Ottawa would jump in for the final one-third share.

But last week, the federal government rejected Toronto's streetcar project as ineligible for the Infrastructure Stimulus Fund, largely because it would not be substantially completed by March 31, 2011.

Still, federal Infrastructure Minister John Baird made clear other city projects could receive stimulus dollars, a move that would free up city dollars.

City officials were tight-lipped yesterday about behind-the-scenes efforts to compile a suitable list of projects for federal funding. "We're doing everything we can to make this happen," said Don Wanagas, press secretary to the mayor.

Since council's funding approval last December assumed Ottawa would directly contribute a one-third share, Ms. Stintz and other councillors say council must bless the new approach to pay for streetcars.

Meanwhile, in yet another wrinkle, a senior official with Bombardier Transportation North America yesterday opened the door to a possible extension past June 27.

"There is no legal reason why the date cannot be reviewed," said Michael Hardt, but made clear any change to the midnight Saturday deadline would set off "an untold list of other issues."


***************************************************************************
Prentice moved wind power funds to oil sands projects: Raitt tape, CBC, Thursday June 11 2009.

Natural Resources Minister Lisa Raitt is heard on tape saying she believes the environment minister pushed to divert funds earmarked for wind energy to oil patch projects during pre-budget negotiations, says a report on Thursday.

The Halifax Chronicle Herald published a previously unreleased excerpt of a five-hour conversation between Raitt and her former aide, Jasmine MacDonnell.

The Jan. 30 conversation was apparently recorded inadvertently while the two were being driven around Victoria. The digital recording device landed in the hands of a Chronicle Herald reporter after reportedly being left in a Parliament Hill washroom.

On the tape, Raitt says she believes Environment Minister Jim Prentice redirected wind power funds to the Clean Energy Fund, a $1-billion fund for research and development in alternative energy sources, mostly in the oilpatch.

Prentice represents a Calgary riding that's home to many in the country's oil industry.

In the recording, MacDonnell can be heard telling Raitt that the Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA) had sent letters to its supporters about the lack of funding in the Jan. 27 budget.

MacDonnell then appears to read from a CanWEA letter claiming the organization knew help for the industry was part of the federal budget until it was removed late in the process.

"We know that the proposal was actively promoted and pushed by Minister Raitt. In fact, it is our understanding that it was actually part of the budget until it was taken out very late in the process," says the letter, according to the Chronicle Herald.

Raitt denies she told anyone from CanWEA about the budget negotiations and speculates the leak could have come from either the Finance Department or her own.

"Someone in Finance talked," Raitt says on the tape, reported the newspaper. "Am I going to get blamed for this?" She later speculates that someone at the Natural Resources Department could have been the source of the apparent leak, says the report. Raitt adds that she didn't know the proposal was dropped from the budget late in the process.

"I would have no way of knowing that. I understand that's what happened. My suspicion is, what I told you, that Jim took the money for his Clean Energy Plan," she said.

"They said, 'Ah, they don't need it.' There should never have been any choice. No one asked my opinion on it. If they had, I would have lobbied. Maybe that's why I'm invited to P and P [the priority and planning committee of cabinet]. Oh, the prime minister's not going to like that."

Raitt is also heard saying she won't "put up with the whining of CanWEA," and says wind producers are not making use of existing funds allocated to the industry.
Not a story: Prentice

Federal Environment Minister Jim Prentice has denied that he was mentioned on the recording. (CBC)Prentice told the Chronicle Herald he has not been mentioned in the recorded conversation.

"Well, let's be clear. I've listened to the transcript in question. It doesn't say Jim Prentice at any point," he said outside the House of Commons on Wednesday.

"It doesn't use the words oil industry or oilsands at any point. It doesn't use the word pandering at any point. And so, really, this isn't much of a story."

The recording, revealed earlier this week by the Chronicle-Herald, has been a source of embarrassment for Raitt. She issued an emotional apology on Wednesday after the newspaper published an earlier segment of the conversation in which she called the shortage of medical isotopes a "sexy" issue that she should take credit for fixing. She also expressed doubts about the abilities of her colleague, Health Minister Leona Aglukkaq, to handle "hot" issues. Raitt has since apologized to Aglukkaq.

Opposition MPs have demanded her resignation, but Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he has confidence in her abilities.

The recording was released after Nova Scotia Supreme Court Justice Gerald Moir rejected an application by MacDonnell on Monday for an injunction blocking the Halifax Chronicle Herald from publishing a story about its contents.

MacDonnell resigned last week after leaving secret documents related to Canada's nuclear industry at CTV's Ottawa news bureau.


***************************************************************************
In Depth: Fort Chipewyan, CBC, November (?) 2008.

Note: this is a truly excellent reporting on this situation. I have copied it here but without the numerous links to backup & supporting documents - maybe later I will fill in those links. In the meantime ... GO READ IT!

The isolated community of Fort Chipewyan, named after the First Nations who inhabited the area, was the first European settlement in Alberta in 1788. Sitting on the far northeastern tip of Alberta, this community of about 1,200, also known as "Ft. Chip," can only be reached by an ice road for a small portion of the year, or by boat or plane. Its isolation makes food expensive, and many in this community still rely on hunting, trapping, fishing and gathering throughout the year for their food.

But these days, many people in Fort Chipewyan say they can no longer trust the environment that has sustained them for so long. Their community is downstream from what is often referred to as largest industrial project on the planet – Alberta’s oilsands. And it shares shores with Saskatchewan’s Uranium City, which supplied the world with most of its enriched uranium for many years.

Over the past decade, residents of Fort Chipewyan say, they have watched too many people die from cancer and other illnesses. Many now suspect something in their water is slowly poisoning them. Hunters and trappers say they no longer dip their cups over their canoes to get a drink of water, and sales of expensive bottled water have increased.

Dr. John O'Connor

Dr. John O'Connor was Fort Chipewyan's doctor and medical examiner from 2000 to 2007.

The community’s suspicions, which were based on anecdotal experience at that time, seemed to have been substantiated when Dr. John O’Connor, the community’s long time fly-in physician and the medical examiner for the region, spoke out publicly in March 2006 about seeing higher-than-expected rates of cancer and other diseases.

Since then, questions have lingered about whether O'Connor's concerns were scientifically supported. Nevertheless, Fort Chipewyan has [missing link] made international headlines and its apparent health problems have become a key rallying point in campaigns being waged around the world by environmentalists against Alberta’s so-called "dirty oil."

Dr. O'Connor on cancer rates:
[missing link]CBC story Mar. 10, 2006 | Cancer rate in Fort Chipewyan cause for alarm: medical examiner
[missing link]Listen Mar. 10, 2006 | O’Connor interview Audio icon (7:14)

After O’Connor spoke to CBC News in March 2006 about his observations, several other health professionals came forward with similar concerns, including the head nurse of Fort Chipewyan’s nursing station, Georg MacDonald, and Donna Cyprien, the director of Nunee Health, Fort Chipewyan’s Health Canada-funded health authority.

However, O’Connor and the other health professionals weren’t the first to sound the alarm about apparent health problems in this community. Dr. Michel Sauvé, an internist and president of the Fort McMurray Medical Association, had raised similar concerns three years earlier during government licensing hearings for two oilsands operations: Shell Oil and Canadian Natural Resources Ltd.

Read EUB's final decisions:
[missing link]Jan. 27, 2004 | CNRL's oilsands application (PDF)
[missing link]Feb. 5, 2004 | Shell Canada's application (PDF)

Recommendations for a health study

In both cases, the Alberta Energy and Utilities Board (now the Energy Resource Conservation Board or ERCB) recommended a study of the health of residents living in the oilsands region. Shell Oil also promised to complete a human health baseline assessment, which First Nations say was never completed.

Prior to that, the Northern River Basins Monitoring Program, a provincial panel studying water issues in northern Alberta, had suggested baseline health studies should be done of northern aboriginal communities, after panel members became concerned about reports of elevated health problems.

[missing link]Read the full report Mar. 1999 | Northern River Basins Human Health Monitoring Study (PDF)

After O’Connor’s claims received national media attention in March 2006, Health Canada and Alberta Health and Wellness pledged to do a thorough study of health problems in Fort Chipewyan. Alberta’s health minister at the time, Iris Evans, pledged to do whatever was necessary to alleviate the community’s fears and address the concerns of area doctors and nurses.

Officials said it would take up to a full year to do a thorough study, and they promised to include the community and its doctor in the planning of any study.

Surprise release

Just a few months after those promises were made, Alberta Health and Wellness surprised the community, health professionals and the media when, on July 14, 2006, it suddenly released a health analysis of Fort Chipewyan residents at a licensing hearing for another oilsands company, Suncor.

The company was requesting government approval for its Voyageur upgrader and mine expansion, which was opposed by residents of Fort Chipewyan and members of the area’s tribal council. The residents were asking the Alberta Energy and Utilities Board (now the ERCB) to stall the project until a health study could be completed.

[missing link]Read the full report Jul. 14, 2006 | Alberta Health's Fort Chipewyan Health Data Analysis (PDF)

Alberta Health and Wellness’ response was to table its analysis, which was based on a search of a provincial billing database and a cancer registry database.

The analysis showed overall cancer rates in Fort Chipewyan were no higher than the rest of the province. It also did not find the three to five cases in 100,000 of cholangiocarcinoma, a rare bile-duct cancer reported by O’Connor, which normally strikes one to two people.

However, the analysis did show elevated cases of two diseases O’Connor was concerned about: Graves (a type of autoimmune disease that causes over-activity of the thyroid gland, causing hyperthyroidism) and kidney (renal) failure. It also showed specific cancers were elevated, including cancers of the blood known as hematopoietics, which oncologists say includes leukemia.

For reasons unknown, the Alberta Cancer Board decided to separate leukemia from hematopoietics for the analysis. Once the figures were combined, blood cancers were double the expected rate (five expected, 10 diagnosed). Nevertheless, Alberta Health determined this was not a statistically significant difference and said there was no cause for concern, and repeatedly said there was no need for further study of Fort Chipewyan..

Incomplete data used

CBC stories:
[missing link]Jul. 19, 2006 | Cancer rates not higher in Fort Chipewyan, investigation concludes
[missing link]Jul. 25, 2006 | Local doctor doubts report on Fort Chipewyan cancer rates

O’Connor immediately called the study rushed and incomplete, and criticized it for failing to include data more recent than the 1995-2005 statistics it was based on.

The lead investigator for the cancer board, Dr. Yiqun Chen, did admit to using incomplete data even for the years included in the analysis because of limitations in the cancer database. She also said a review of medical charts from Fort Chipewyan’s nursing station wasn’t completed for the analysis — something that had been promised to the community.

Members of the Fort Chipewyan and medical communities immediately called for a more thorough study to be done, including an analysis of blood and tissue samples from the community and a close examination of medical charts.

However, the Alberta and federal governments stood by their analysis despite criticism of the methodology from area doctors, and maintained the analysis showed overall cancer rates are not elevated. They said media sensationalism was the only reason there was concern for this community.

Dangerous arsenic

In November 2006, residents discovered a Suncor Energy study predicted via modelling, that arsenic levels in moose meat and other food sources used by the residents in Fort Chipewyan are up to 453 time acceptable limits in terms of cancer risk.

CBC stories:
[missing link]Nov. 15, 2006 | Fort Chip doctor rails against government inaction
[missing link]Nov. 16, 2006 | Imperial, gov't say arsenic scare unfounded
[missing link]Nov. 17, 2006 | Moose meat reports confusing residents

Despite these alarming findings, Fort Chipewyan’s community leaders said they had to send numerous letters to the provincial government demanding further study before Alberta Health and Wellness agreed to investigate arsenic levels in the area. A spokesperson for Alberta’s health minister, Howard May, denied those claims and said a study of the arsenic levels had been initiated as soon as the Suncor report became public.

[missing link]Arsenic levels in food and water Full report: Mar. 2007 | Alberta Health study of arsenic levels in northern communities (PDF)
[missing link]CBC story Apr. 3, 2007 | Mixed reports on safety of eating northern Alberta game

Alberta Health completed its study in March 2007, concluding arsenic levels were much lower in the area than had been reported previously. The new analysis, published in March 2007, found arsenic levels were only 17 - 30 times the acceptable levels, and found they were no higher than samples taken from another northern community.

Given the dramatically conflicting findings, the people in Fort Chipewyan asked for a more comprehensive, independent and peer-reviewed analysis. The Alberta government has not responded to the request.

Official complaint

O'Connor is investigated
[missing link]CBC story Mar. 5, 2007 | Hamlet supports whistleblower MD
[missing link]Audio: Mar. 5, 2007 | Erik Denison reports Audio icon (6:19)

In March 2007, senior medical officials at Health Canada used the Alberta Health analysis as the basis for a complaint against O’Connor, accusing the physician of causing undue alarm in Fort Chipewyan and causing mistrust of government. They filed the complaint with the Alberta College of Physicians and Surgeons, which began an investigation.

College rules prevented O’Connor from talking publicly about the probe, but when news of the complaint surfaced, members of the community and fellow doctors rallied around him, suggesting it was an attempt to muzzle the outspoken physician. Members of the Alberta Medical Association (March 2007) and The Canadian Medical Association (September 2007) passed motions supporting a doctor’s right to speak out publicly about concerns for his patients.

[missing links]Associations support O'Connor Mar., 2007 | AMA motion passed (PDF) Sep. 5, 2007 | CMA motion passed

About six months after the complaint was filed, the investigator looking into the complaint decided there was no foundation for the allegations against O’Connor. However, the college’s registrar, Trevor Theman, decided further investigation was needed and overruled the decision. Two years later, the college still hasn’t ruled on the allegations.

Doctor leaves town

After his son was violently robbed on the streets of Fort McMurray, in 2007 O’Connor decided to move back to the East Coast where he had started his practice in Canada.

Dr. Michel Sauvé is president of the Fort McMurray Medical Association.

Dr. Michel Sauvé again took up the cause of Fort Chipewyan. Sauvé, an internal medicine specialist and then president of the Fort McMurray Medical Association, called for a thorough examination of toxins in the blood and tissue of area residents. But politicians continued to say there was no cause for concern in the community.

However, the government did agree to initiate a province-wide examination for toxins in blood samples taken from pregnant women for toxins. The scientist in charge of that examination said the sample size being taken from Fort Chipewyan was too small to produce specific results for the community. The government still has not released the results that were promised in the fall of 2007.

Community activism

With the continued refusal by federal and provincial governments to undertake a comprehensive study, residents in Fort Chipewyan demanded their community leaders conduct their own study.

New chiefs were elected in two of the area’s largest First Nations — Allan Adam of the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation in 2007 and Roxanne Marcel of the Mikisew Cree in 2008 — along with numerous new council members with promises to do more about the health concerns.

The new leaders began working with local health authorities to commission studies of contaminants in Lake Athabasca.

The Timoney Report:
[missing link]Read the full report: The Timoney Report (PDF)
[missing link]CBC story Nov. 8, 2007 | Study contradicts earlier findings on N. Alberta water quality
[missing link]Audio: Nov. 8, 2007 | Randy Henderson of CBC Radio's Trailbreaker program speaks with Kevin Timoney Audio icon (7:04)

The first of these was the Nov.11, 2007 Timoney Report, written by independent ecologist and statistician Kevin Timoney.

Study finds cause for concern

Timoney’s analysis found numerous deficiencies in the industry-funded and operated monitoring of water quality in the oilsands region.

"We found that there is reason to be concerned that levels of arsenic, mercury and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are higher than would be considered safe," Timoney told CBC News. Timoney's analysis found these higher than expected sedimentary contaminants and some of the most toxic contaminants appeared to be rising with increased development.

Alberta Health Minister Dave Hancock, while admitting he had not read Timoney's report, said it contained nothing new and did not give him any reason to be concerned for the health of people drinking the area's water. Officials with Alberta Environment’s oilsands division also said there was little connection between contaminants found in the sediment of the lake where the residents get their water, and the safety of their drinking water.

Those officials also said any sedimentary contaminants are naturally occurring because the area is rich in petroleum.

However, at the same time, federal officials responsible for the quality of Fort Chipewyan’s drinking water admitted to CBC News that they do not test – and had never tested – the settlement’s water for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), the petroleum-based contaminants Timoney found in lake sediment that, according to his report, are linked to cancers and other illnesses.

[missing link]The Polaris report Nov. 11, 2007 | Read the full report (PDF)

Following a November 2007 report it commissioned, Suncor admitted that one of its oldest tailings ponds, the Tar Island dike, had been leaking millions of litres of wastewater daily into the groundwater, which flows into the Athabasca River. Tailings ponds are lake-sized bodies of toxic wastewater from oilsands operations. They hold the waste left over after the oil is washed out of the oily sand. The industry’s tailings ponds currently cover 130 square kilometres.

[missing link]Expert report prepared for Suncor Nov., 2007 | Read the full report (PDF)

In May 2008, members of Alberta’s Liberal opposition questioned why Suncor had never been fined for this admitted leak. The province replied that water quality in the area of the leak was being closely monitored by the industry-funded [missing link] Regional Aquatic Monitoring Program, and any toxins from the tailings pond were highly diluted and not of any concern.

A May 2008 report by the Polaris Institute, an Ontario-based safe water advocacy group, added fuel to the controversy: It found the water quality in Fort Chipewyan was among the worst in Canada.

Cancer board launches new investigation

New study launched:
[missing link]Transcript: May 20, 2008 | Lee Elliot discusses Alberta Cancer Board analysis with CBC's Erik Denison (PDF)
[missing link]CBC story May 22, 2008 | 'Comprehensive' review of Fort Chipewyan cancer rates announced

With a growing number of local, national and international media outlets and non-governmental organizations calling for further study of Fort Chipewyan’s water, the provincial Department of Health and Wellness decided to re-analyze the area’s cancer rate. The Alberta Cancer Board’s (now the Alberta Health Services Board) spokesperson and director of media relations, Lee Elliot, told CBC News and other media outlets the study would be comprehensive and researchers would involve the community and local health officials.

Elliot told CBC reporter Erik Denison that researchers would take steps to ensure their data were accurate, including talking with elders who have kept lists of deaths in the community. Community members in Fort Chipewyan have long said staffing shortages, turnover and poorly trained nurses have led to incomplete record-keeping in the community’s small nursing station.
Cancer board refuses access

[missing link]Jul. 9, 2008 | Media request (PDF)
[missing link]Jul. 14, 2008 | Cancer board's reply (PDF)

Elliot refused to release to the media a copy of the research protocol being used for this analysis, despite a joint request by reporters from Alberta’s four major media organizations: CBC News, Canwest Global, Sun Media Corp. and The Canadian Press.

Elliot also told CBC News the study would follow the [missing link]American Centre For Disease Control cancer cluster protocol.

[missing link]CBC obtains study's ethics application Read the ethics application (PDF)

However, CBC News obtained the application for the new analysis, which contained an outline of the researchers’ plans. It showed the new analysis would be limited to a chart review and a review of a provincial cancer database. It also showed Elliot, the provincial cancer board’s media relations director, would be a co-investigator on the new analysis.

Community rejects study

On Nov. 10, 2008, before the study was even completed, Fort Chipewyan First Nations’ leaders and their health authority, the Nunee Health Region, rejected the cancer board’s analysis.

They said the board had not fulfilled its promise to involve them in the study’s design, and had failed to consult with them about its progress. The chair of the Nunee Health Board, which is responsible for health in the community on behalf of Health Canada, said he had only been invited to two meetings: The first in February 2008 to introduce the researchers who would conduct the study, the other in August 2008 to inform the community that the study had been completed.

Doctors who treat the community also said they were not closely involved with research, to ensure cancer cases were not being missed. Liam Griffin, Fort Chipewyan’s fly-in physician, said his involvement was limited to an invitation to attend two community meetings with residents and leaders. He attended one but, due to a schedule conflict, could not attend the other.

Griffin said he was sent a list of people who had died in the community and was asked to verify whether it was accurate. Given his limited time in the community, he said, he found that task difficult.

O’Connor, the community’s doctor between 2000 and 2007, said the researchers had not consulted him about cancer cases in the community.

Sauvé, then president of the Fort McMurray Medical Association, which represents doctors that treat patients from Fort Chipewyan, said the researchers did not consult him, and said none of his members had told him they had been consulted.

Sauvé was also critical of the provincial cancer board’s outline for its research. He said the board’s new analysis appeared to exclude a significant number of suspected cancer cases because it would only look at lab-confirmed diagnoses, which are part of the Alberta Cancer Registry. He said doctors in remote communities such as Fort Chipewyan often do not fly patients out for confirmation via biopsies if the cancer is advanced and the diagnosis does not require lab confirmation. As well, Sauvé added, many First Nations family members are reluctant to allow autopsies for cultural reasons.

Sauvé said the long-recommended comprehensive health study of Fort Chipewyan's First Nations has still not been completed and is still needed.


***************************************************************************
800 BA workers set to work unpaid, BBC, Thursday 25 June 2009.

British Airways has said 800 workers have volunteered to work for nothing for up to a month, following the airline's request to cut costs.

Another 4,000 workers are taking unpaid leave, while 1,400 people have volunteered to work part-time.

The airline had appealed to 40,000 workers to work for nothing for up to one month, to help the firm cut costs. BA's chief executive Willie Walsh has already agreed to work unpaid in July, forgoing his month's salary of £61,000. The airline, which is struggling in the downturn, says the move will save £10m.

Many firms across different industries have been reducing their workforces and cutting workers' hours in a bid to save costs during the economic downturn.

"What makes BA stand out is that it is asking workers to work for nothing for a period, rather than simply reducing pay through fewer hours," said Jane Amphlett, an employment lawyer with Finers Stephens Innocent.

'Fantastic' response

In May, BA reported a record annual loss of £401m, stemming partly from higher fuel bills and other costs.

Following the response from workers, Mr Walsh said: "This is a fantastic first response. I want to thank everyone who has volunteered to help us pull through this difficult period."

He added: "This response clearly shows the significant difference individuals can make."

Mr Walsh said staff could volunteer for the programme later in the year too.

Starting in July, the 800 workers have the chance to stagger the days worked unpaid over a period of up to six months, with the pay deduction spread over three or six months. Those volunteering to work part-time can do so for a period of between one month and one year, before another review is expected later in 2009. Similarly those on unpaid leave can take the time off for up to a year.


***************************************************************************
Somalis watch double amputations, BBC, Thursday June 25 2009.

Somali Sharia AmputationsSomali Sharia AmputationsSomali Sharia AmputationsSomali Sharia Amputations

Hardline Islamists in Somalia have carried out double amputations on four men for stealing phones and guns. They have each had a hand and foot cut off after being convicted by a Sharia court in the capital earlier this week.

More then 300 people, mainly women and children, watched as masked men cut off their limbs with machetes.

The four men reportedly admitted to the robberies, but were not represented by a lawyer and were not allowed to appeal against their sentence. The al-Shabab group, which controls much of southern Somalia, has carried out amputations, floggings and an execution in the port of Kismayo but such punishments are rare in the capital.

'Help, help, help!' one of them shouted - Eyewitness Mohamed Abdi.

The amputations were carried out in the open in front of an al-Shabab military camp in the north-east of Mogadishu. A local resident said the four men cried out during and after the amputations. Each man had his right hand and left foot cut off.

"'Help, help, help!' one of them shouted," Mohamed Abdi told the BBC.

Eyewitnesses estimate the age of the four men - Aden Mohamud, Ismail Khalif , Jeylani Mohamed, and Abdulkadir Adow - to be between 18 and 25. Mr Abdi said the whole process took about an hour to complete.

'Torture'

Human rights lobby group Amnesty International has condemned the amputations. "These punishments amount to torture," said Tawanda Hondora, Amnesty's Africa deputy director. The group says that committing torture could amount to a war crime.

After the four were sentenced to double amputations on Monday, mosques in the area announced through their loud speakers that the amputations would take place at 0800 local time on Thursday.

Al-Shabab spokesman Ali Mohamud Rage told journalists that the amputations were a warning to all thieves. "If they are caught red-handed in similar circumstances, they will face amputation," he said. He also said al-Shabab would look after the welfare of the amputees.

On Monday, the court had said it was too hot for the sentence to be carried out on that day as an amputation in such conditions could lead the accused to bleed to death. The punishments carried out in Kismayo have shocked many Somalis, who traditionally practise a more tolerant form of Islam than al-Shabab's strict Wahabi interpretation. Onlookers at the amputation in Mogadishu on Thursday declined to comment when asked for their reaction.

President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed, a moderate Islamist, took office in January but even his introduction of Sharia law to the strongly Muslim country has not appeased the hardliners.

The government has not carried out any amputations under its version of Sharia.

Since 7 May, al-Shabab and its allies have been locked in ferocious battles with pro-government forces. The president has declared a state of emergency and has appealed to Somalia's neighbours to send troops to help.


***************************************************************************
Swallow self-respect? Er, no thanks, Rick Salutin, Friday June 26 2009.

Here's a strike reality check

There's an excuse-me quality to the Toronto civic employees' strike. “We knew it was not going to be a popular strike,” said union leader Ann Dembinski. She didn't request support, just “for the public to be understanding.” Further down the (picket) line, it's the same. “We're not asking for anything. We just want to keep what we've got,” said a district captain.

That's modest enough, even apologetic. They don't want to suffer a pay increment far below the 3 per cent that Toronto police, firefighters and transit workers got recently. They don't want to give back the right to accumulate sick-leave benefits by coming to work assiduously, a benefit common across the country. They probably knew, before Globe columnist Marcus Gee told them, that the world “has entered an era of austerity.” They just don't want to be forced to swallow human excrement - a technical term in labour relations.

Some strike issues are not primarily economic. You have to look at yourself in the mirror, and at your kids, and it's harder to do with a mouthful of the stuff. It can happen to anyone. Recently, one employer after another has tried to redefine pension clauses from the guarantee of “defined benefits” to the RSP-style crapshoot of “defined contribution.” Mostly, they've succeeded.

There are other non-economic factors, such as hypocrisy. Few things motivate people like the sight of it. The Toronto strikers may know that Sir Fred Goodwin banked millions of pounds in bonuses for wrecking the Royal Bank of Scotland and that Sarah Kramer got a $114,000 bonus plus $317,000 severance when she was pushed out the door at eHealth Ontario. Margaret Wente says the Toronto strikers want a (sick leave) bonus “just for showing up.” But they've seen that, in sectors such as finance, you get far more not just for showing up but for botching things, losing billions and pulverizing the global economy.

It's true there's something odd about collective bargaining in the public sector. In the private sector, market forces impose a reality check, so that unions try not to bargain a company into bankruptcy. On the other hand, free trade and globalization have now so badly tilted market forces that companies impose their will just by threatening to move. Truck assemblers at Navistar in Chatham, Ont., for instance, face company contract demands that will basically destroy their lives and community. The alternative is a more direct version of the same: The plant just bolts.

In the public sector, it's different. Toronto can't shift its daycare and playground employment to Kentucky or Oaxaca. Public-sector workers, you could say, are the hedge-fund managers and bank presidents of the working class in that they get away with murder. Relatively speaking, of course. The most they really get away with is jaywalking, in comparison with the bankers.

But in most strikes, strong non-economic motives are also at work: moral, emotional, etc., and the latter often predominate. These can include hostility toward those whose garbage you regularly handle but who rarely show appreciation. Or, from the other side, columnists and talk-show callers who, for their own reasons, identify with the overdog.

There are normal considerations of fairness (as in, “that's not fair”) that begin very young, when the smallest kids notice that the bigger ones usually get their way simply due to strength. And there's the widespread preference to go on strike rather than swallow human excrement.

Not everyone gets the choice. The cornered truck workers in Chatham told the company, in a piercing phrase: “We will not be exercising the right to strike.” Toronto's civic workers still retain a margin for action, in the name of self-respect. Perhaps they felt they didn't have a right not to strike.

Down.

Sunday, 21 June 2009

Sunday meditation, father's day

Up, Down.

The Tree Out My Window June 21 2009The Tree Out My Window June 21 2009The Tree Out My Window June 21 2009

damned camera! Olympus Stylus, i used to have a CyberShot, at least i knew how to turn the fucking flash off!

so it looks like i should be cleaning my window then ... somewhere here i have already told that story ... yeah, I am fixing my window, the tree i have already revealed in introjection / Dia Mundial do Meio Ambiente / World Environment Day
Humpty Dumpty, John Tenniel
Buddhists do have hell it turns out ...


Death will be so quick to swoop on you;
Gather merit till that moment comes!
Wait till then to banish Laziness?
Then there’ll be no time , what will you do?

“This I have not done. And this I am only starting.
And this --- I’m only halfway through ... ?
Then is the sudden coming of the Lord of Death
Humpty Dumpty, John TennielAnd oh, the thought “Alas I’m finished.”

Your tear-stained cheeks, your red and swollen eyes
Such will be the depths of your distress.
You’ll gaze into the faces of your hopeless friends,
And see the coming servants of the Deadly Lord.

The Memory of former sins will torture you
The screams and din of hell break on your ears.
With very terror you will foul yourself;
What will you do then, in such extremity of fear?
Humpty Dumpty, Blanche Fisher Wright
And if you are so scared while still alive,
Like fishes writhing on the open ground,
What need to speak of pain unbearable
In Hells created by past evil deeds?

The hells in which the boiling molten bronze
Will burn your body, tender like a baby’s flesh ---
All is now prepared, your former deeds have done it!
How can you lie back, so free of care?

All the King's horses and all the King's men, John TennielTake advantage of this human boat:
Free yourself from sorrow's mighty stream
This vessel will be later hard to find.
The time that you have now, you fool , is not
For sleep.



Alek Wekfrom something called Shantideva's Bodhicharyavatara (The Way of the Bodhisattva (The Enlightened being)), possibly endless parentheses to get it straight :-) sounds like good advice, makes me think of Robert Herrick's To the virgins, to make much of time and some others like it ...

Alek Wek Pirelli Calendar Herb Rittssimple thoughts, "he was like a tree" or "he was a tree," metaphors for which you have a concrete operator in each hand so to speak, 'him' in one hand and 'a tree' in the other and ... smush ... it becomes more-or-less understood, and then there are other, transcendental metaphors like "God is Love," where at best you have a notion in one hand and nothing in the other and when you go ... smush ... it is you who smushes :-)

Alek Wekand thinking of principe e princesa working itself out in Brasilian culture, even the poor girls are princesas and it is in the nature of dialectic that the principes follow suit, not 'follow' exactly, more walk in parallel, and i wonder if there is a clue in the martial side of structures containing notions of princesses and princes? that is, kings - which makes it essentially about war & domination instead of love

THREE PACKS TODAY!    HOKEY DOODLE MAN!    THIS CAN'T LAST!

thinking about Alek Wek along the way ... no surprise there ... what else do fat old fucked-up white guys think about? she has written a book Alek: From Sudanese Refugee to International Supermodel, story of her struggle from Sudan to New York, suffers from psoriasis apparently, none of it could have happened without family, an architect in the mix ...

coming back around to princesas for a sec ...
Jimmy Soul! If you wanna be happy,


If you wanna be happy for the rest of your life
Never make a pretty woman your wife
So from my personal point of view
Get an ugly girl to marry you

A pretty woman makes her husband look small
And very often causes his downfall
Alek: From Sudanese Refugee to International SupermodelAs soon as he marries her, then she starts
Doin' the things that will break his heart

But if you make an ugly woman your wife
You'll be happy for the rest of your life
An ugly woman cooks your meals on time
An she'll always give you peace of mind

Don't let your friends say you have no taste
Go ahead and marry anyway
Though her face is ugly and her eyes don't match
Take it from me, she's a better catch


complete nonsense of course, i tried it both ways, neither worked out very well ... could have spent more time cleaning the windows and finding a garden to dig in ...

Voltaire, Candide & Cunegonde"All that is very well," answered Candide, "but let us cultivate our garden."

time enough for that yet maybe

Down.

Saturday, 20 June 2009

Braidwood Inquiry - the shit finally hits the fan.

Up, Down.

Stop the presses! At long last, the grand mucky-muck pooh-bah of the RCMP, William Elliott has spoken:
"The RCMP will not be making further comment on this issue."

Such arrogance may never be seen again from an RCMP Commissioner, until, that is, they can Taser you for speaking out. (but I am willing to bet that they will indeed have more to say, lots more, when they are finally forced to tell the truth :-)

William Elliott RCMPWilliam Elliott RCMPWilliam Elliott RCMPWilliam Elliott RCMP: His teeth, I've enacted, Shall all be extracted, By terrified amateurs. W. S. Gilbert, The Mikado
Cartoons from, and thanks to: Gaping Void & The Nonconformer, and the original Pooh-Bah from Gilbert & Sullivan's The Mikado.

PS: wait a minute here! what is needed is something to corroborate Dick Bent's email, it won't likely be another email BUT it might just be Paul Pritchard, check this out: The Braidwood Chronicles: the Pritchard factor on Dawg's Blawg.

you may be a business man of some high degree, they may call you Doctor, they may call you Chief, but you're gonna have to serve somebody, yes indeed, you're gonna have to serve somebody

in case you missed the story: Cops planned to Taser Dziekanski: RCMP memo / Inquiry adjourned until Sept. 22, complete with the text of the email, and, Federal government lawyer Helen Roberts' statement (aka, the Official Reply).

the only problem is that it may not be real enough shit ... they will all bail on Dick Bent - he's toast, he was "mistaken" or simply "wrong," and since what he says bears no resemblance to the rest of the lies they have been telling ... maybe it will wash ...

I am wondering why they let it out? (it was the RCMP who informed their Lawyer, Helen Roberts about the 'oversight') the obvious motivation is that they were afraid that it might leak out later so they tried to steal their own thunder so to speak, but why would they think it would necessarily leak out? unless they know or they guess that there is someone in the inside who is about to blow the whistle? maybe even more than one? man, if 50 of 'em did it we could put them back on the fifty dollar bill eh?


Just when you thought the reputation of our national police force couldn't sink any lower comes news of the existence of an internal RCMP e-mail that contradicts the sworn testimony of the four Mounties involved in the fatal confrontation with Mr. Dziekanski.

        Gary Mason, Globe and Mail, Saturday June 20 2009.

who ARE these people?
where did they come from?
what country do they live in?


Richard C. (Dick) Bent is a prairie boy who moved to the big cities (see bio below), remember that it was Bent who tried to whack Mike Webster's pee-pee when Mike stepped out of line (in the RCMP's and in Bent's own estimation) but Mike Webster would not be cowed;

Al Macintyre, aka Alastair Donald Macintyre, I don't know about - a 35 year man according to the Braidwood transcripts, still looking for something more detailed, he was definitely on-side for the killing of Ian Bush, you can see him on one of the pictures holding up pictures of Paul Koester:
Dick Bent RCMPDick Bent RCMPDick Bent RCMPDick Bent RCMPAl MacIntyre RCMPAl MacIntyre RCMPAl MacIntyre RCMPAl MacIntyre RCMP
Wayne Rideout also don't know anything yet except what he looks like:
Wayne Rideout, Al MacIntyre RCMPWayne Rideout RCMPWayne Rideout RCMPWayne Rideout RCMPWayne Rideout RCMPWayne Rideout RCMPWayne Rideout RCMPWayne Rideout RCMP
and another Little Bo Peep, Helen Roberts, a lawyer, a woman moved to tears by something, I wonder moved by what? because she was caught out? because she would rather be on the other side? who can say? from her statement below, we can see that she is resourceful and competent, at least the second time around she is, trying to make a plausible argument and more-or-less succeeding ... except of course that it is all bullshit lawyer's talk & bafflegab:
Helen Roberts RCMPHelen Roberts RCMPHelen Roberts RCMPHelen Roberts RCMPHelen Roberts RCMPHelen Roberts RCMPHelen Roberts RCMPHelen Roberts RCMP





***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
Appendices:
1. Commission and public deserve an explanation, Gary Mason, Saturday June 20 2009.
2. 2008 Bio of Dick Bent, The Society for the Policing of Cyberspace (POLCYB).
3. Federal government lawyer Helen Roberts' statement, June 19, 2009.
4. Cops planned to Taser Dziekanski: RCMP memo, Neal Hall, June 19, 2009.
5. William Elliott's statement on the Braidwood inquiry, June 19, 2009.
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
***************************************************************************
Note: This article is not in the regular Globe website for some reason, so I had to lift it from the Globe Plus site where they post pdfs (ugh!) of every page.

Commission and public deserve an explanation, Gary Mason, Saturday June 20 2009.

The death of Polish immigrant Robert Dziekanski is threatening to engulf the RCMP in one of the biggest scandals in its history.

Just when you thought the reputation of our national police force couldn't sink any lower comes news of the existence of an internal RCMP e-mail that contradicts the sworn testimony of the four Mounties involved in the fatal confrontation with Mr. Dziekanski.

Federal government lawyer Helen Roberts, representing the RCMP, seemed unable to explain why the November, 2007, e-mail surfaced only now, as lawyers involved in the inquiry were set to begin their final submissions. Ms. Roberts cried as she apologized for the oversight.

Meantime, former judge Thomas Braidwood, who is heading the inquiry, fumed. He was appalled by the omission and he should have been. The e-mail's existence, and the provocative and potentially explosive claim it contained, temporarily threw the inquiry into chaos.

So what to do?

It looks like the four officers will be called back to explain on the stand the discrepancy in their testimony, delaying a final commission report, possibly for months.

All four officers had testified that they had no plan as they headed towards the airport to respond to a call of a distressed male behaving violently. The officers said they had decided to taser Mr. Dziekanski only after deciding that the travel-weary, unarmed man posed a threat to their personal safety.

But in a Nov. 5, 2007, e-mail from Chief Superintendent Dick Bent, a senior member of the force, to his superior, RCMP Assistant Commissioner Al Macintyre, a different picture emerges.

Chief Supt. Bent wrote that, in a conversation with Superintendent Wayne Rideout, the officer in charge of the investigation into Mr. Dziekanski's death, it was revealed that the four officers "had discussed the response en route and decided that if he [the distressed man] did not comply that they would go to CEW [conducted energy weapon]."

In other words, they had decided early on to use the taser.

Their actions were premeditated.

Lawyers representing the four officers said yesterday that Chief Supt. Bent got it wrong. The officers insist no such conversation occurred.

And we're supposed to believe them.

The same officers who told RMCP investigators immediately after the incident that they had tasered Mr. Dziekanski only twice, when video evidence would later show it was five times. Who said Mr. Dziekanski was putting up a fight when they decided to taser him successive times, when the video showed the poor man writhing in pain, fighting for his life after he was zapped the first time.

The same Mounties whose testimony provoked calls of a cover-up inside the force.

Supt. Rideout is also saying Chief Supt. Bent got it wrong.

And we're supposed to believe him.

The same Supt. Rideout who admitted on the stand that it was his decision not to correct wrong information the RCMP gave the public about the circumstances of Mr. Dziekanski's death because it might somehow compromise the "integrity of criminal investigation."

The same lead investigator who didn't think it might be a good idea to go back and re-interview the four officers after video surfaced that contradicted the almost-identical statements each offered to the RCMP about what happened. (Even though all four insisted they never talked among one another about what they might tell investigators.) Good lord.

Chief Supt. Bent is now saying he doesn't remember the conversation with Supt. Rideout. I guess not. And I guess we're supposed to just accept that. Pretend it never happened. Something that Chief Supt. Bent made up, I guess. What a disgrace. And you know, he'll get away with saying that too. He is a member in good standing of the old boys' club that runs the RCMP. He won't get thrown under the bus.

The contents of the memo aside, I'm dying to know why news of the e-mail didn't surface until yesterday. Helen Thomas, she of the tearful apology, couldn't say what happened. There was some explanation about it being on a CD-ROM that didn't get looked at. Such a key piece of information? Didn't alarms go off somewhere, maybe inside the RCMP, when the officers were saying one thing on the stand and an e-mail was floating around that said something entirely differently?

Why didn't someone step forward well before now and alert commission lawyers to the oversight?

Did someone think the e-mail could be kept secret? Did Ms. Thomas hand it over to commission counsel only because it was going to come out some other way?

What happened? Not only does the inquiry deserve an explanation but the public does too.

This is scary stuff.


***************************************************************************
2008 Bio of Dick Bent, The Society for the Policing of Cyberspace (POLCYB).

Chief Superintendent Richard C. (Dick) Bent
Deputy Criminal Operations Officer -
Community, Contract and Aboriginal Policing Services
Royal Canadian Mounted Police “E” Division
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Born in Saskatchewan, Dick Bent joined the RCMP in 1974. After completing basic training he was transferred to Alberta where he served in a variety of roles for twenty years.

After working in general duties and traffic roles in a number of detachments throughout Alberta, he was transferred to Division Headquarters in Edmonton where he worked in the Complaints and Internal Investigation Section and then Major Crimes as a Team Leader.

In 1993 Dick was transferred in charge of a Sub/Division General Investigation Section responsible for all serious crime investigations in the Peace River region of Alberta.

In 1994, he was promoted to the rank of Inspector in Nova Scotia where he worked in planning the 1995 G7 Summit in Halifax, in the Staffing and Personnel Section, and finally as the Officer In Charge of the Federal Policing Branch for the Province of Nova Scotia.

In 1997, he was transferred to the RCMP National Headquarters in Ottawa where he gained exposure in a number of areas including the Finance, Commissioner’s Secretariat, Criminal Intelligence, and Community, Contract and Aboriginal Policing Directorates. He then worked for two years in Executive/Officer Development and Resourcing.

In 2002, Dick was promoted to the rank of Chief Superintendent and transferred to the position of the Deputy Criminal Operations Officer in British Columbia responsible for all Federal Policing in the province.

In 2005, Dick assumed his current role as the Deputy Criminal Operations Officer in British Columbia responsible for Community, Contract and Aboriginal Policing in the province.


***************************************************************************
Federal government lawyer Helen Roberts' statement, June 19, 2009.

Statement presented by counsel for the Government of Canada, Helen Roberts, to Justice Braidwood, commissioner of the Braidwood Commission of Inquiry:

You are likely now aware, Mr. Commissioner, as counsel for the participants are already aware, that Counsel for Canada mistakenly overlooked providing documents earlier in response to a request from Commission counsel for documents relating to the RCMP media strategy. Jan Brongers and I learned about the omission on Monday, advised Commission counsel of this on Tuesday and provided those documents to Commission counsel on a CD-ROM on Wednesday.

On behalf of the Government of Canada, I would like to sincerely apologize to you, Mr. Commissioner, to Commission counsel, to counsel for the participants, and to the participants themselves for the inconvenience. Canada continues, as it has all along, to fully support the work of this Commission.

I would like to add that both the CBSA and the RCMP have been fully cooperative in providing documents to us for disclosure purposes. In this, they have been guided by counsel. Any concerns about document production properly lie with counsel.

Among the documents that had been overlooked is an RCMP e-mail that we anticipated would be of interest to the Commission. That was an e-mail from C/Supt. Bent to Asst. Commr. Macintyre. The e-mail was provided separately to Commission counsel and to counsel for all of the participants on Tuesday. We did not locate any other e-mails that contained similar information.

It is the third paragraph of the e-mail that is of interest. C/Supt. Bent wrote: "Finally, spoke to Wayne and he indicated that the members did not articulate that they saw the symptoms of excited delirium, but instead had discussed the response en route and decided that if he did not comply that they would go to CEW."

Wayne is Supt. Rideout, who has already testified at this Inquiry. CEW is of course a conducted energy weapon or taser.

We have interviewed both C/Supt. Bent and Asst. Commr. Macintyre to find out their evidence about this e-mail. C/Supt. Bent has advised us as follows:

1. The e-mail was sent because Dep.Commr. Bass had asked whether the members had used the CEW because they believed Mr. Dziekanski was exhibiting signs of excited delirium. He understood the question was being asked because RCMP policy then suggested the use of CEWs to restrain persons exhibiting signs of excited delirium, so that restraint could be effected as quickly as possible and medical attention then sought.

2. He sent an e-mail to C/Supt. McGowan asking for a synopsis of the members' accounts, and "especially, why the CEW member went to taser right away".

3. He spoke to Supt. Rideout, who advised the members did not report observing signs of excited delirium.

4. His e-mail indicates that he understood Supt. Rideout to say that the members "had discussed the response en route and decided that if he did not comply that they would go to CEW".

5. He has no recollection of the conversation with Supt. Rideout at this time.

6. Given the flurry of activity at the time, it is entirely possible that he misunderstood what he was told.

7. He has checked other e-mails sent and received around the time, and has no other e-mails that shed any light on this.

8. He has no notes of the conversation with Supt. Rideout.

9. He did not receive any other information suggesting the members had formulated a plan to use the CEW prior to arriving at the airport.

Asst. Commr. Macintyre has advised as follows:

1. The question originated with Dep. Commr. Bass. He passed on the question to C/Supt. McGowan and copied others, including C/Supt. Bent.

2. He received the e-mail from C/Supt. Bent.

3. He received no other information suggesting that the members discussed the response en route and had a plan.

4. He did not respond to C/Supt. Bent's e-mail.

Supt. Rideout was also interviewed and I understand Mr. Pringle will speak to Supt. Rideout's recollection.

As you are aware, the four members who attended the airport all testified that they did not formulate a plan prior to their encounter with Mr. Dziekanski. Indeed they were criticized for not formulating a plan. The only thing that was said was Cst. Bentley's question as to whether any of the officers was carrying a taser and Cst. Millington's response.

The IHIT file has been searched, and there is no evidence that the members formulated a plan to use the taser prior to the encounter with Mr. Dziekanski.

It is our conclusion from these interviews that C/Supt. Bent misunderstood information provided by Supt. Rideout.

However, if you wish to hear from C/Supt. Bent and/or Asst. Commr. Macintyre, we have asked them to stand by so as not to delay the Inquiry. They are available to attend the Inquiry to testify about the e-mail on 10 minutes' notice. They will however not be able to testify today about other matters without an opportunity to prepare and consult counsel.

Once Canada submitted an application for, and was granted, participant status, Canada provided RCMP documents to Commission counsel. It shared the Reports to Crown Counsel and the evidence generated by the IHIT investigation, including statements, photographs, videotapes, experts' reports and records seized from other agencies. It was my understanding — and this has been fortified by your comments during the Inquiry - that it is not part of your mandate to examine the IHIT investigation itself. For that reason, documents generated by the IHIT investigators during the course of the investigation, such as e-mails, task reports and notebook entries, were not shared — except in the case of Cst. Hoivik, where Commission counsel expressly requested his notes, and these were produced as they were relevant to his evidence about the seizure of exhibits and his sketch of the scene.

In addition to the evidence generated by the IHIT investigation, Commission counsel requested, and were provided with, the media advisories prepared by Sgt. Lemaitre and Cpl. Carr, the notes made by Cpl. Carr, and the notes and e-mails of Supt. Rideout. It was by oversight that they were not provided earlier with the other RCMP media strategy documents.

It is our understanding that we have now provided the Commission with all of the CBSA and RCMP documents that are relevant to your mandate. That being said, we welcome hearing from Commission counsel if you feel there are other kinds of documents that would be of assistance to you in preparing your report. Canada is now and has always been fully supportive of the Inquiry and will do its utmost to assist you.

Thank you.


***************************************************************************
Cops planned to Taser Dziekanski: RCMP memo, Neal Hall, June 19, 2009.

Inquiry adjourned until Sept. 22

VANCOUVER — An e-mail found last week that sheds light on possible misconduct by senior RCMP officers has thrown the Braidwood inquiry into the death of Polish immigrant Robert Dziekanski into disarray.

The e-mail, sent by RCMP Chief Supt. Dick Bent to RCMP deputy commissioner Al Macintyre, suggests for the first time that the four Mounties who responded to a call at the Vancouver International Airport planned to use a Taser against Dziekanski — contrary to what they testified during the inquiry.

Dziekanski, 40, died after being hit five times with a Taser by RCMP officers in October 2007.

The e-mail, dated Nov. 5, 2007, said: "Finally, spoke to Wayne (Rideout) and he indicated that the members did not articulate that they saw the symptoms of excited delirium, but instead had discussed the response en route and decided that if he did not comply that they would go to CEW (conducted energy weapon).

"He has asked investigators for a synopsis and should have it by noon tomorrow."

Supt. Rideout is the former commanding officer in charge of investigating Dziekanski's death.

Lawyer Helen Roberts, who represents the RCMP, broke into tears as she told retired judge Thomas Braidwood, who is heading the inquiry, that her office received the e-mail in late April but never opened the CD for the document files until last week.

"I do say, it was by oversight that this occurred," she said. "Canada continues, as it has all along, to fully support the work of this commission."

Roberts said Bent was mistaken in his e-mail and that the officers did not formulate a plan to use the Taser as soon as possible.

"As a result of (our office's discovery) of this e-mail . . . the IHIT (Integrated Homicide Investigation Team) file has been searched and there is no evidence in the IHIT file that the members formulated a plan to use the Taser prior to the encounter with Mr. Dziekanski," Roberts said.

"It is our conclusion from these interviews that Chief Supt. Bent must have misunderstood information provided to him by Supt. Rideout."

The lawyers for the four RCMP officers said their clients deny they formulated a plan to Taser Dziekanski.

RCMP Commissioner William Elliott echoed Robert's statement that the e-mail was not released to the inquiry due to an "oversight." "Unfortunately in an exercise of this magnitude, such an oversight can occur," Elliott said in a news release Friday. He said the RCMP will "continue to co-operate fully with the inquiry."

Braidwood decided the e-mail will require new testimony, so he adjourned the inquiry until Sept. 22.

"I find the delay in disclosing this material to the commission to be appalling," he said.

Commission counsel Art Vertlieb said the late disclosure of the e-mail as evidence had resulted in a "complete disruption of the process."

"It's a stunning turn of events," Don Rosenbloom, the lawyer representing the government of Poland at the inquiry, told reporters after the commissioner ordered the adjournment.

"The documents that have just come to our attention include a critical e-mail from very high up in the RCMP chain of command, disclosing that the officers decided in a premeditated way, 'en route' to the scene, to use the Taser if Mr. Dziekanski did not comply."

Rosenbloom said the 11th-hour disclosure "is totally inconsistent with testimony given under oath." He added the e-mail goes to the heart of the issue of police fabrication. During the hearing, he said, "We were alleging they (the four Mounties involved in the airport incident) were fabricating their story."

The inquiry was supposed to have ended its public hearings on Friday.

Dziekanski, who did not speak English, had been travelling for more than 24 hours when he died. He had been in the airport for more than nine hours, looking for his mother.

***************************************************************************
This is the transcript, in its entirety, of the e-mail that was read out at the Braidwood inquiry June 19, and which led to an adjournment until September.

E-mail sent Nov. 5, 2007
From: Dick (Richard) Bent — 'Media Strategy — Release of the YVR Video'
To: Al Macintyre

Al, spoke with Wayne Rideout today about our strategy for the release of the video. He had a couple of concerns.

First, he didn't think we should be providing any explanation for what was transpiring but instead just say the inquest will take evidence under oath, etc. I went through the rationale and said we need to have an explanation otherwise our detractors will put their own spin.

Second, as we're going to have someone speak to this, he suggest that it should be someone other than (RCMP spokesman Cpl.) Dale Carr otherwise we may lose the perception of independence. He would rather have someone separate from IHIT (Integrated Homicide Investigation Team) do this. We both think a use of force expert would be ideal. Gregg Gillis has not been involved in this investigation so is independent. I suggest we have Gregg do the narrative of what is happening.

Finally, spoke to Wayne and he indicated that the members did not articulate that they saw the symptoms of excited delirium, but instead had discussed the response en route and decided that if he did not comply that they go to CEW (Conducted Energy Weapon commonly known as Taser). He had asked investigators for a synopsis and should have it by noon tomorrow.

(Signed) Dick


***************************************************************************
William Elliott's statement on the Braidwood inquiry, June 19, 2009.

B.C. - RCMP Commissioner makes statement about Braidwood Inquiry

The Commissioner of the RCMP, William Elliott, wishes to make the following statement regarding today's events at the Braidwood Inquiry:

- From the outset, the RCMP has cooperated fully and participated fully in the Inquiry.

- We have produced thousands of documents to our legal counsel for their review and for them to transmit all relevant material to the Commission.

- Commissioner Braidwood was informed that a specific document was not provided and he himself accepted the Government of Canada's sincere apologies for this oversight.

- This was simply an oversight. Unfortunately in an exercise of this magnitude, such an oversight can occur.

- It was the RCMP, working with our legal counsel, who brought this oversight and this document to the attention of the Commission.

- The Commission indicates that it will thoroughly look into the matter, including into the relevance, if any, of the specific document, about which there are significant questions.

- The RCMP is as disappointed as all of the parties involved in this inquiry that there will be a delay in the completion of the Inquiry as a result of this unfortunate development.

- We will continue to cooperate fully with the Inquiry. The RCMP wants all of the facts surrounding this tragic event to be known so that we can learn as much as possible and make any further required changes to the RCMP's policies and practices.

The RCMP will not be making further comment on this issue.



***************************************************************************




***************************************************************************


Down.